Skip to main content

Crows hold grudges against individual humans for up to 17 years

Published on November 8, 2024

A single crow on a light post
Spring arrives on the UW Seattle campus in April 2020.

Reported by Eric Falls for Earth.com

Crows are more than just black-feathered figures cawing from treetops; they are masters of memory and grudges, with cognitive abilities that defy our expectations.

While we often admire birds for their bright plumage and lilting songs, there is a deeper layer to their behavior that remains unseen.

Birds are more intelligent than most people realize, especially when it comes to recalling those who pose a threat.

Recent research has illuminated this startling dimension of avian behavior, revealing that crows — members of the avian elite — can hold grudges for up to 17 years.

This discovery showcases the profound capacity of the crows’ memories. The study also sheds light on the social transmission of knowledge about threats within bird communities.

Studying crows and grudges

The research project, led by experts at the University of Washington, was launched in 2006.

Professor John Marzluff, an environmental scientist, initiated the study by donning a fearsome mask and temporarily trapping seven crows. He identified them with leg rings before their safe release.

In subsequent years, the professor and his assistants sporadically wore the same mask — strolling the university campus while feeding the resident crows.

Marzluff recalled an incident while wearing the mask when 47 out of 53 crows he encountered vehemently scolded him.

This was a substantial increase from the original seven crows that were captured, suggesting that these birds could recognize threatening humans and pass on this knowledge to their kin.

The sound of silence

The climax of this fascinating study came in 2013 when the number of aggressive caws reached their peak, only to gradually decrease.

By September 2023 — 17 years since the experiment began — not a single scolding crow was heard on one of Marzluff’s masked walks.

Seeing behind the mask

Another intriguing facet of the study involved the use of a “neutral” mask, bearing the likeness of Dick Cheney, who was the vice president of the United States at the time.

Those sporting the Cheney mask fed the crows without causing them any distress, and were subsequently spared of avian wrath.

As the research progressed, unknowing volunteers were roped in to wearing the masks, ignorant of the “dangerous” or “neutral” categorization by the crows.

One such volunteer found himself at the center of an avian uproar, confirming the crows’ skill in discerning and remembering threats.

Dive-bombing attacks by crows

A report published in Mail Online shares some other instances of crows with a grudge. In Dulwich, a posh London suburb, residents reported instances of crows executing dive-bombing attacks.

One resident, Alison Frean, shared her harrowing experience, revealing that she had been targeted by crows on three separate occasions when trying to exit her car.

This had a profound impact on the residents, as they chose to stay indoors, attempting to avoid any crow confrontations.

Intelligence of crows

Crows never cease to amaze with their incredible intelligence, and it isn’t confined to recognizing threats and holding grudges.

Prior research indicates that crows possess the talent to devise tools and even count.

Stories abound of crows dropping nuts onto busy roads, waiting for cars to crack them open, and then retrieving the food once the traffic stops.

Some crows have even figured out how to use sticks to extract insects from tree bark or fashion hooks from twigs to fish out food from hard-to-reach places.

The study from the University of Washington undeniably contributes to affirming the crows’ place in the intelligence hierarchy among birds.

Continue reading here.


The crows inhabiting our cities hold grudges against humans for 17 years
Search by categories

Twitter Feed